Missouri Woman Solves Mystery of Gravestone Found in Backyard

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

Sarah Merritt and her husband recently bought a house in Crystal City, Missouri, and during a cleanup of the backyard, they discovered a rectangular piece of granite that had been used as a weight on a portable basketball goal. When they turned it over they realized it was a gravestone.

“My husband he was like, ‘Sarah this is a headstone.’ He was freaking out, I was freaking out, I was like it cannot be a headstone because that is really creepy, it’s weird,” Merritt toldĀ KMOV.

The headstone had the name of James Carr on it and showed that he was a World War II veteran who died in 1995. She was worried that it might be stolen so she called police.

She also posted a photo on Facebook.

“And less than 12 hours later we found the actual family members that it belongs to,” said Merritt.

KMOV went to Sacred Heart Cemetery in Crystal City and found the grave of James “Rick” Carr and saw that it also has a similar marker at the foot of the grave.

A relative said that the gravestone found in Merritt’s backyard had a misprint, was never used and had been discarded by the monument company. It’s unclear how it ended up in the possession of the previous owners of the home.

The relative also said that James Carr was called Rick or Ricky by family and friends and that he had worked at the PPG plant for many years, and served as a bartender at the local VFW club.

Merritt said she’s just glad that the gravestone wasn’t stolen and is now in the hands of Carr’s relatives.

“Oh I’m happy, I’m really happy,” said Merritt.