Story Summary

New U.C. Logo Sparks Criticism

A new logo for some University of California advertising and documents is intended to be more modern and streamlined, but has prompted criticism from students and alumni.

Story Timeline
Previous Next
This story has 2 updates

logo400By suspending further use of its much-maligned new logo, University of California officials hope to get beyond the controversy.

“While I believe the design element in question would win wide acceptance over time, it also is important that we listen to and respect what has been a significant negative response by students, alumni and other members of our community,” Daniel M. Dooley, UC’s senior vice president for external relations, said in a statement.

Dooley defended the contemporary logo, which was designed by an in-house team and started appearing six months ago. Critics had latched onto “an unfortunate and false narrative, which framed the matter as an either-or choice between a venerated UC seal and a newly designed monogram,” he said. The graphic would not have replaced the official seal on diplomas or official letterhead, but was meant to bring a more modern look to websites and publications in UC’s fundraising, recruiting and public affairs campaigns. The symbol was accompanied by the text “University of California,” a fact its critics ignored, officials complained.

But the controversial logo will not disappear immediately. The changeover has begun on websites, although the modern graphic will remain on paper materials already printed and those in production. The change “is not going to happen overnight. It’s not like we can flip a switch,” said Jason Simon, the UC system’s director of marketing communication.

Simon said that though he was disappointed by the negative reaction to the logo, “it was time to move on” and focus on more important issues facing the 10-campus university system.

Opponents had complained that the large “U” — which surrounded a fading “C” — was ugly, incomprehensible and made the university seem like a crass PR machine. They lobbied for the restoration of UC’s century-old seal, with its “Let There Be Light” motto, a drawing of an open book and the 1868 date of the system’s founding.

Lt. Gov. Gavin Newsom, a voting member of the UC Board of Regents, had joined that chorus — as did whoever tweets for Gov. Jerry Brown‘s dog, Sutter.

“Awesome victory,” wrote one contributor to a Facebook petition formed to oppose the logo. “For once in government, common sense prevailed,” another petitioner wrote Friday.

Tomo Hirai, a 2010 UC Davis graduate, had mocked the new logo by posting his own online version with a spinning “C” — resembling a computer operating system that was endlessly stalled. On Friday, he said he was surprised by UC’s retreat. “In my four years at UC, it was really hard to get the administration to listen to anything the students wanted,” he said. So the reversal, he said, “was pleasant news.”

UC has not decided what the next step will be: designing a new logo, expanding use of the traditional seal or, Simon said, coming up with a compromise that freshens the old seal in ways that “honor our traditions and the past and also the amazing and incredible innovations that are happening on our campuses every day.”

Los Angeles Times

Local News
12/08/12

Negative Reaction to New UC Logo

logo400CALIFORNIA (KTLA) — The University of California unveiled a new logo for advertising and documents, but not everyone was happy about the change.

Some students and alumni started an online petition to drop the new and simpler logo, which is a solid “U” containing a “C” resting at the bottom.

They wanted the 10-campus system to use the traditional circular medallion that shows an open book, the motto “Let There Be Light” and the 1868 date of UC’s founding.

Critics wrongly assume that UC is eliminating the traditional symbol, UC system spokeswoman Dianne Klein said.

That symbol will remain on all diplomas and official correspondence.

The old logo does not reproduce well in small size on Internet pages and that UC wanted something more visually contemporary and versatile, especially for online efforts to seek donations and recruit applicants, according to Klein.

Advertisement