A man suspected of shooting two Orthodox Jewish men as they left Los Angeles synagogues earlier this week has been charged with federal hate crimes.

The separate shootings happened about 24 hours apart outside two synagogues in the Pico-Robertson neighborhood.

During a news conference on Friday, United States Attorney Martin Estrada announced the suspected gunman, Jaime Tran, 28, has been charged with federal hate crimes, which he said has no place in the community and will be prosecuted “to the fullest extent of the law.”

The first shooting took place just before 10 a.m. Wednesday on the 1400 block of Shenandoah Street. The second shooting happened around 8:30 a.m. Thursday on the 1600 block of South Bedford Street, roughly two blocks from the first location.

Tran was taken into custody in Riverside County Thursday evening.

Charging documents allege that Tran intentionally targeted the two men as they were leaving religious services in the predominantly Jewish community. Both men were dressed in traditional clothing that could likely identify them as Orthodox Jews, the documents state.

Guy Tieb was leaving the Pinto Shul, an Orthodox synagogue, when he says the gunman fired at least three shots at him, hitting him in the arm. Feb. 17, 2023.
Guy Tieb was leaving the Pinto Shul, an Orthodox synagogue, when he says the gunman fired at least three shots at him, hitting him in the arm. Feb. 17, 2023.

Officials said both shootings involved a man driving a 2012 Honda Civic who fired at the victims at close range with a handgun.

In a recorded interview with Tran, he allegedly told investigators that he sought out a “Kosher market” on the review site Yelp in order to find his targets, whom he identified as Jews based on their “head gear.”

A history of antisemitism

Those charging documents allege that Tran has a history of making antisemitic remarks, including emails he sent to former classmates last year in which he described Jews as “primitive” and blamed them for lost revenue from the COVID-19 pandemic.

He also allegedly sent threatening messages to Jewish former classmates in which he wished them death.

The first shooting victim told investigators that he saw the Honda approach him as he left the religious service. As he turned his back to the vehicle while getting into his car, he said he heard a loud bang and felt sudden pain as he realized he had been shot in the back.

The second victim, Guy Tieb, said he had just left the Pinto Shul when he made eye contact with the gunman who had stopped his car beyond the crosswalk. As he crossed the street behind the car, he heard three gunshots and discovered he had been shot in the upper arm.

“I heard three shots…bam, bam, bam. Three times” Tieb told KTLA.

In response to the shootings, authorities increased security and patrols in Jewish neighborhoods and at schools and places of worship.

How Tran was arrested

Using witness statements and security footage from the scene, authorities positively identified the vehicle used in both shootings and were able to trace the registration to Tran.

Tran was eventually tracked down to the Palm Springs area, the court documents state. Police in Cathedral City responded to reports of shots fired and located Tran with an AK-style firearm and a handgun near the wanted vehicle.

He was taken into custody and interviewed by detectives. During those interviews, Tran allegedly took responsibility for both shootings and said he targeted both men based on their traditional Jewish clothing.

Tran, who is homeless and had been living in his vehicle for more than a year, said he purchased the firearms used in the crimes from a stranger in Arizona.

Text messages and emails were uncovered that showed Tran had harassed and threatened Jewish classmates in previous months, specifically wishing them dead because of their religion.

In one of the recovered text message, Tran allegedly sent a text to a classmate that said “I want you dead, Jew.” Another reads: “Someone is going to kill you, Jew.”

Because of his admission about the shooting and the previous threats made to members of the Jewish community, investigators determined there was enough evidence to charge Tran with federal hate crimes.

Community leaders react

Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass, who described herself as growing up in the Pico-Robertson area, thanked authorities for working together to bring the suspected shooter into custody.

“My administration is resolute against hate, and we have made it a chief component of our public safety agenda,” Bass said. “I know that the LAPD and the FBI and the U.S. Attorney’s Office share in that mission. And so today we’re not just here to stand in solidarity around this week’s shootings, we are here with locked arms against all forms of hate and bigotry and discrimination.”

Deputy Chief David Kowalski with the Los Angeles Police Department’s counterterrorism bureau said cooperation between law enforcement agencies likely “prevented additional persons, either here in Los Angeles or in neighboring cities from being hurt or killed,” although he did not say whether or not Tran had plans to attack additional civilians.

Representatives from the Anti-Defamation League decried the shootings and urged all Americans to stand up against the rise of antisemitic sentiment across the globe.

A rabbi from a local synagogue laid much of the blame on social media, calling for companies to do a better job moderating the content of their sites and urging users of TikTok and Twitter to report antisemitic posts when they see them.

“When you speak off the record to law enforcement, whether it’s in New York, or Chicago, or Los Angeles, and you ask them what has changed in the last five years, they all say the same thing — social media,” said Rabbi Abraham Cooper from the Simon Wiesenthal Center. “Government will do its share, but we also need the social media giants to step up.”

Cooper added that, despite Tran’s arrest, Jewish families will be “looking over their shoulders” as they head to places of worship for Sabbath. But he urged local Jews to continue to visiting their synagogues and churches, arguing it is important not to give “bigots, racists, antisemites and terrorists a victory.”

Both men wounded in the shootings survived and are expected to recover, and Cooper said he was thankful to not be attending any funerals related to the shooting.

Estrada said the shootings highlighted the importance of community and looking out for one another.

“It is critically important, especially in an area as diverse as Los Angeles, with one of the largest Jewish populations in the country, that we celebrate diversity and celebrate our differences, that we appreciate the value and humanity that each of us has, and that we stand together to oppose hate,” Estrada said.

In addition to the federal hate crimes charges, Tran was also charged with two counts of attempted murder. Jail records indicate he’s currently being held on $2 million bail.

He was expected to make his first appearance in court Friday afternoon.

If convicted, he could face a maximum sentence of life in prison.