Secretary of State Mike Pompeo said Thursday he still doesn’t know whether a summit between President Donald Trump and North Korea’s leader will take place on June 12.
Pompeo, speaking to reporters in New York after two meetings with a senior North Korean official, said the two sides have made progress toward a successful meeting between Trump and North Korean leader Kim Jong Un, but that challenges remain.
“We’ve made real progress in the last 72 hours in terms of setting the conditions” for a successful summit, Pompeo said, but he added, “make no mistake about it, there remains a great deal of work to do.”
“Through these meetings I’m confident we’re moving in the right direction,” Pompeo said, noting that US teams that in Singapore and at the Demilitarized Zone between North and South Korea have also been meeting with North Korean counterparts.
Pompeo added that the two countries are at a “pivotal moment” and that it would be “nothing short of tragic to let this opportunity go to waste.”
And he said he believes that North Korea’s leaders are “contemplating a strategic shift… one their country has not made before,” but added that “it should not be to anyone’s surprise” that roadblocks emerge.
The uncertainty and frustration that often characterize negotiations with North Korea have been compounded, in part, by Trump himself. The president abruptly called off the potentially historic meeting in a letter to the North Korean leader that some analysts saw as a classic “Art of the Deal” attempt to gain leverage. The difficulty in closing gaps between the North Korean and US positions is adding another kind of uncertainty.
“After listening to Secretary Pompeo today, I would argue North Korea is still unwilling — and maybe never will be willing — to satisfy the Trump Administration’s goal of a denuclearization agreement before any summit in Singapore,” said Harry Kazianis, Director of Defense Studies at the Center for the National Interest. “And make no mistake: this is the key to getting a summit finalized.”
Trump said earlier that meetings with a North Korean delegation in New York had gone “very well” and that he expects the delegation to travel to Washington on Friday to deliver him “a letter from Kim Jong Un.”
Pompeo confirmed that the official he’d met with, former North Korean spy chief Kim Young Chol, would be traveling to Washington to deliver a letter to the President.
“These are all positive signs,” said Joel Wit, co-founder of 38 North, a website that tracks North Korea. “Everything that’s happened since Trump threatened to cancel the summit, these are all positive signs. The issue is what is the deal? And I don’t know the answer to that right now, I don’t think anyone knows.”
Pompeo refused to talk about the “elements, the shape of an agreement” at his press conference, but the administration says it wants the complete, verifiable, irreversible denuclearization of the Korean peninsula – an unwieldy phrase that has given rise to the acronym CVID.
There seems to be disagreement about how exactly to make that happen, though.
Pompeo and National Security Adviser John Bolton have said they want a quick process, with Bolton in particular reportedly concerned that the North Koreans will use any longer term process to wring concessions from the US.
Trump on the other hand, has indicated some openness to a slower approach, saying, “it would certainly be better if it were all in one. Does it have to be? I don’t think I want to totally commit myself.”
Kazianis said that hammering out an agreement, or at least a framework is vital before any meeting takes place.
“If Trump were to go to Singapore and give Kim Jong Un the photo op of a lifetime, photos that would legitimize Kim and be on par with [President Richard] Nixon being photographed with [Chinese leader] Mao [Zedong], he needs to make sure he is not getting played,” Kazianis said. “And so far, there is no evidence that Pyongyang is truly serious about nuclear disarmament beyond aspirational pledges.”
A second or a third… or none
Last week Trump canceled the summit after a North Korean official harshly criticized Vice President Mike Pence. On Thursday, he raised the possibility that it will take more than one meeting with the North Koreans to settle the issue of denuclearization.
Meetings so far, Trump said, “have been very positive,” but he added, “it doesn’t mean it gets all done at one meeting; maybe you have to have a second or a third. And maybe we’ll have none.”
Pompeo echoed that point, telling reporters that the work will take time and effort. “This is going to be a process that will take days and weeks, there will be tough moments, tough times,” Pompeo said.
In separate remarks, Trump told Reuters that he would like to see those meetings take place as quickly as is practical.
The President also told the news agency that North Korean denuclearization would cover the country’s missiles as well as its weapons, and that he will be very happy when he can lift sanctions on the country.
But Pompeo indicated that the two sides haven’t closed the gap on the central issue of what exactly North Korea will do and how to define “denuclearization.”
The Trump administration is trying to convince North Korea that possessing nuclear weapons makes it less safe, not more.
But North Korea, which has seen its nuclear program as an existential insurance policy has not committed to denuclearization yet. In April, Kim Jong Un said that his country’s quest for nuclear weapons was “complete” and that it ” no longer needs” to test its weapons capability.
Pompeo acknowledged it would be hard to convince Pyongyang to see the US point of view on nuclear weapons. “Make no mistake about it, President Trump, this administration completely understands how hard this problem is,” the top US diplomat said.
Acknowledging that North Korea would need assurances in order to be convinced that their security would be greater without weapons, Pompeo added that “the true test comes when we actually achieve that.”
After his New York meetings with Kim, Pompeo tweeted Thursday that he had had “substantive talks with the team from #NorthKorea. We discussed our priorities for the potential summit between our leaders.”
Kim Young Chol, the former head of North Korea’s Reconnaissance Bureau, an espionage and special operations organization, is believed to have been involved in a torpedo attack that sank the South Korean warship Cheonan in 2010, killing 46 South Korean sailors. Because he is under US sanctions for that attack, Chol is getting a waiver from the US government to allow him to travel beyond the 25 mile radius of New York City and the United Nations to visit Trump.
A senior State Department official added that, “the meetings went well. They made progress,” and attributed the early end to the fact that the talks were successful.
Pompeo and Kim had also met Wednesday night for a 90-minute dinner.
State Department spokeswoman Heather Nauert said Thursday that Pompeo told her that the meetings “were great last night, but there is still a lot of work to be done.”
Pompeo and Kim were looking to agree on the content of summit talks and what more needs to be done to make the potentially historic meeting happen, according to a senior State Department official.
Pompeo made clear, that North Korea “must do things they haven’t done before,” the official said, and must show the administration in these meetings what they are willing to do before the summit can take place.
“We are looking for something historic,” the official said. “We are looking for something that has never been done before.”